Fletch - I would offer easier navigation options (no ironic pun intended) within the review. Sometimes I want to jump to the performance or conclusion, and I can't tell where it is. It would also be easier if comments didn't add to the page count of the review - makes it hard to tell where the review stops and comments begin. Otherwise, I love the site and your reviews are top notch!

How about even more glowing reviews of the Garmin products. You have never ranked a Garmin less than a 3. So let's have more 4.5s and 4.9s of 5. And more trashing of Tom Tom. There is not enough of that. You need to lower the ratings on them too. I mean a 3.6 is WAY too high.

I would do a side by side comparisons (with video if possible).

When choosing a GPS, I bought a Magellan 4250, TomTom Go 730 and Garmin Nuvi 760, placed all 3 on my dash and drove around for 10 days (with all three active). I tested them intensely in Toronto, Niagara Falls (both in Canada) and Buffalo, USA.

Both Garmin and Magellan would tell me to turn right/left when prohibited several times (especially in Downtown areas). Both Navteq devices would navigate me through longer (distance-wise) roads - ones that had more stop signs, speed-bumps and stop-lights.

I would not have realized of these GPS imperfections unless I had all 3 calculating routes for me. Also the quality of Map rendering and route re-calculation speeds were more obvious this way.

Video Comparison Reviews would be fantastic and very welcome.

Fletch,
Coming from someone who sells GPS' for a living, you do a great job. There will always be people who rag on you for having an opinion but when it comes down to it, nobody in our office prefers a TomTom over a Garmin. Keep up the good work!