« Navigon 7100 Review | Main | New York Times Says GPS Costs Half as Much This Year vs. Last Year. GPS Outselling PCs (and pretty much everything else). »


December 4, 2007

GPSmagazine 2007 Holiday Buyer's Guide


GPSmagazine 2007 Holiday Buyer's Guide

It's here! Whether you're a starving student or a money-is-no-object type, GPSmagazine has the info you need to buy the right GPS this holiday.

It's good news for GPS shoppers this year; prices have dropped steadily, and it's now possible to buy a decent GPS for under $200, and even the more expensive units are considerably cheaper than last year's round-up.

By popular demand I've sorted the models this year by price, sorted in the following way:

Note: don't see a particular GPS you're considering buying? Be sure to check out the full list of ratings and reviews.

  Under $200
1st Place
Garmin nuvi 200

$193 - Amazon

Garmin nuvi 200 - Garmin's entry level unit, the nuvi 200 just recently dropped below $200. It doesn't have bluetooth, traffic, or text-to-speech (so it won't announce actual street names, just generic turns), but it does have good maps and the same excellent routing engine as Garmin's more expensive models. The nuvi 200 is easy to use and small enough to fit in a shirt pocket. For about $25 more you can get the nuvi 200W, a wide-screen version of the 200.
2nd Place
Magellan Maestro 3200
Magellan Maestro 3200 - Okay, so it's actually slightly above $200, but the Magellan Maestro 3200 is a solid entry-level GPS that offers some unique features not found on other GPS units. Like the Garmin, the 3200 doesn't have bluetooth, traffic, or text-to-speech. The 3200 has fewer POIs than the Garmin and its routing engine isn't quite as good. Still, the 3200 is a decent unit for the price and owners love the easy route exclusion feature that lets you exclude a specific road from the route, as well as Magellan's handy "Locate" screen that tells you where you are and what's nearby.
3rd Place
Magellan Maestro 3100

Magellan Maestro 3100 - The 3100 is a budget GPS that offers good, reliable, basic navigation for under $150 in a package that's easy to use. Its got fewer POIs than more expensive models, and lacks bells and whistles like bluetooth, traffic, or text-to-speech, but it's a better GPS than TomTom's ONE 3rd Edition. This GPS is a good starter GPS for students, or those on a strict budget.

4th Place
TomTom ONE 3rd Edition

$149 - Circuit City
$149 - Best Buy
$149 - Radio Shack

TomTom ONE 3rd Edition - Like the other similarly priced models, the ONE 3rd Edition doesn't have bluetooth, traffic, or text-to-speech. The ONE isn't as good a navigator as the Magellan or Garmin units (TomTom's routing engine is weak), but it's an attractive unit that's relatively easy to use and offers a lot of value for the money.
  Under $300
1st place
Garmin nuvi 650

Garmin nuvi 650 - Costco has this unit for almost $100 less than Amazon. The nuvi 650 has a 4.3" wide screen display, uses SiRF's high performance receiver, has around 6 million POIs, ships with Garmin's 2008 maps, text-to-speech, and can be upgraded for traffic data. Plus, it has a host of travel related features, like an mp3 player, photo viewer, and more.

This is a great GPS and $299 is an unbeatable price.

2nd Place
Garmin nuvi 350

Garmin nuvi 350 - This is the GPS I normally recommend to friends looking for a good GPS that's not too expensive (although given Costco's $299 deal on the 650, which is identical to the 350 but has a wider screen, I'll start recommending the 650). It has excellent routing, current maps, and is easy to use.

When the nuvi 350 was first released it cost almost $1,000. A year later it's still a great GPS and a fantastic bargain for $300. The nuvi 350 uses SiRF's high performance receiver, has around 6 million POIs, ships with Garmin's 2008 maps, text-to-speech, and can be upgraded for traffic data. Plus, the nuvi 350 has a host of travel related features, like an mp3 player, photo viewer, and more. The nuvi 360 is about $30 more expensive, and adds bluetooth so you can use the GPS as a hands-free speakerphone.

3rd place
Magellan Maestro 3250
Magellan Maestro 3250 - The newly released Maestro 3250 sports a new slim design, has maps of the lower 48 States, Canada, and Alaska, 6 million POIs, AAA TourBook data, text-to-speech, bluetooth, voice recognition, SiRF's high performance receiver, and includes a traffic receiver for real time traffic awareness. The Magellan isn't quite as strong at routing as the Garmin units, but it offers a lot of bang for the buck and is a solid performer all around.
  $300 and Up
1st Place
Garmin nuvi 760

Garmin nuvi 760 - My current Editor's Choice, the nuvi 760 is the best GPS I've reviewed to date. If money is no object, go for it. If $665 is too rich for your blood, the nuvi 660 delivers about 90% of the 760's features for $300 less.

If you don't care about Bluetooth or traffic, the nuvi 750 has all the features of 760 minus Bluetooth, and doesn't include the traffic receiver for $478 from Amazon.

2nd Place
Garmin nuvi 660
Garmin nuvi 660 - Last year's Editor's Choice winner, the nuvi 660 is a great GPS and the next best thing if you can't quite afford the nuvi 760. The 660 has a 4.3" wide screen display, SiRF's high performance receiver, bluetooth for hands-free calling, traffic (antenna + 3 months service included), text-to-speech, a built-in mp3 player, photo viewer, and more.
3rd Place
Magellan Maestro 4250

Magellan Maestro 4250 - On paper Magellan's Maestro 4250 looks like an even better GPS than Garmin's flagship 760. While the Maestro 4250 is a good GPS with lots of features, it looses points for poor customer support and a routing engine that's slightly behind Garmin's.

The Maestro 4250 has a 4.3" wide screen display, maps of the U.S. (including Canada & Alaska), has a newer, thinner design, 6 million POIs, bluetooth, traffic, voice recognition, is easy to use, and easily lets you customize the route to avoid certain roads. Also popular is Magellan's "Locate" screen that display your current position and nearby POIs, as well as the ability to display approaching POIs along the highway at each exit.

For those more accustomed to 2-wheeled navigation:

  Best Motorcycle GPS
1st Place
Garmin Zumo 550
Garmin Zumo 550 - Pricey, but it's the best motorcycle GPS you can buy right now.
2nd Place
Garmin Zumo 450
Garmin Zumo 450 - Less expensive than the Zumo 550, the 450 doesn't have text-to-speech, bluetooth, or traffic.

And for the great outdoors:

  Best Outdoor GPS
1st Place
Magellan CrossoverGPS
Magellan Crossover - A good choice for those who want a single GPS for boating, hiking/camping/hunting, and driving. It's not particularly good at any of those tasks, but it does perform all three functions and it a very rugged, water-resistant GPS that's relatively easy to use. It can also be upgraded with more detailed outdoor or marine maps.

 

GPSmagazine 2008 Holiday Buyer's Guide

Most Popular Reviews

Recent Comments

Tien on GPSmagazine 2007 Holiday Buyer's Guide: I got a great deal at Futureshop, I bought the LG LN740($140...

Luis on GPSmagazine 2007 Holiday Buyer's Guide: My Kids buy me a TTGO720, I'm looking into the other 2(Garmi...

KNguyen on GPSmagazine 2007 Holiday Buyer's Guide: The TomTom GPS models have two problems: 1. Sometimes the bo...

TryingMagellan on GPSmagazine 2007 Holiday Buyer's Guide: As of this morning Amazon is selling both the Magellan Maest...

Ed on GPSmagazine 2007 Holiday Buyer's Guide: how about the magellan maestro 4040, $330 at circuit city? ...