« Auto Nav 2000 Plus, Inc. Launches Online GPS Rental Service | Main | Magellan Maestro Firmware 1.22 Posted. Broken Website Doesn't Allow Downloading. Update Pulled. »
|
|

This week I put the nuvi 250 through GPSmagazine's rigorous testing criteria and found out how the newest, budget-friendly nuvi stacks up against the competition (and other nuvi's!).
Figuring out which nuvi is right for you has become a daunting task. With 14 different models to choose from, even the most savvy consumer can find themselves confused. Let's take a look at Garmin's growing nuvi family, and examine the differences.
The 200-series represents the entry level market and are the least expensive nuvi's to date. The nuvi 200, 250, and 270 are identical in every way, except for the map coverage. The nuvi 200 ships preloaded with maps of the 48 U.S. continental states (no Alaska or Hawaii), the 250 ships preloaded with maps of the United States, Canada, & Puerto Rico, and the 270 includes maps of the US, Canada, Puerto Rico, and Europe. All three nuvi 200's use the same NAVTEQ mapping data, share the same high-sensitivity GPS receiver, have the same weight, size, screen, and features.
What's missing from the less expensive 200 series nuvi's? These nuvi's don't have text-to-speech, Bluetooth, traffic, an mp3 player, or a headphone/audio out jack. For a complete overview of the nuvi offering, take a look at the comparison chart below:
Garmin nuvi Feature Matrix
|
200 |
270 |
360 |
370 |
650 |
670 |
|||||
Screen Size |
3.5" |
3.5" |
4.3" |
3.5" |
3.5" |
3.5" |
3.5" |
4.3" |
4.3" |
4.3" |
4.3" |
Map Coverage |
US (48 states) |
NA |
NA |
NA & EU |
NA or EU |
NA or EU |
NA & EU |
NA or EU |
NA or EU |
NA & EU |
NA or EU |
Text-to-Speech |
N |
N |
N |
N |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Bluetooth |
N |
N |
N |
N |
N |
Y |
Y |
N |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Receiver |
SiRF |
SiRF |
SiRF |
SiRF |
SiRF |
SiRF |
SiRF |
SiRF |
SiRF |
SiRF |
SiRF |
FM Transmitter |
N |
N |
N |
N |
N |
N |
N |
N |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Live Traffic |
N |
N |
N |
N |
Opt |
Opt |
Y |
Opt |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Battery Life |
5 hrs |
5 hrs |
5 hrs |
5 hrs |
8 hrs |
8 hrs |
8 hrs |
3-7 hrs |
3-7 hrs |
3-7 hrs |
3-7 hrs |
Weight |
5.2 oz |
5.2 oz |
6.1 oz |
5.2 oz |
5.1 oz |
5.1 oz |
5.1 oz |
6.2 oz |
6.2 oz |
6.2 oz |
6.2 oz |
MP3 Player |
N |
N |
N |
N |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Photo Viewer |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Travel Assistant |
N |
N |
N |
N |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
3.5mm headphone jack |
N |
N |
N |
N |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
MSRP $ |
$428 |
$482 |
$589 |
$642 |
$969 |
$965 |
$899 |
$749 |
$799 |
$1099 |
$999 |
Street Price $ |
$230 |
$280 |
$299 |
$399 |
$370 |
$425 |
$475 |
$425 |
$550 |
$660 |
$640 |
Buyers looking for an integrated MP3 player, travel assistant, traffic, or integrated Bluetooth functionality will need to look to the more expensive nuvi 300 lineup:
Those interested in a wide-screen display, built-in FM transmitter (for using your car's stereo to hear nuvi's audio prompts / music), and real-time traffic will need to look to the more expensive nuvi 600-series. All 600-series nuvi share the same 4.3" wide-screen (480 x 272) display, and have the same travel features / mp3 player as the 300 series nuvi's. Here's how the 600-series nuvi models breakdown:
Confused? Don't be. The simple way to view the nuvi matrix is this: 200-series are basic navigation. 300-series include travel features, MP3 player, and Bluetooth. 600-series mirror the 300-series nuvi, but are offered in wide-screen, and offer the FM transmitter option.
The nuvi 250 includes the following items in the box:
The nuvi 200-series units don't include a leather carrying case, as the more expensive nuvi's do.

Figure 1: Garmin nuvi 250, Front
As mentioned previously, the nuvi 200, 250, and 270 all use identical hardware. Looking at the front of the nuvi 250, there are no visible controls. All operations are performed via the 3.5" touch screen.

Figure 2: nuvi 250's Updated Design
One of the first things you notice about the nuvi 250 is that it's the first nuvi hardware re-design in almost 2 years. The 300 and 600 series nuvi's all share the same light gray, squared plastic case design. The 200-seris nuvi's sport a two-tone look, and have a more streamlined case that narrows at the edges. *Note that the photo above may not be shown to correct scale - both the nuvi 250 and 350 share the same 3.5" 320-by-240 QVGA antiglare screen.
The second thing you notice about the nuvi 250 is that unlike the 300 and 600 series nuvi's that use a fold-out patch antenna, the nuvi 250 has an internal antenna that isn't visible and does not need to be opened when navigating.
The nuvi 250 feels more solid than previous nuvi's. Although the nuvi 200 is almost identical in weight to the nuvi 300 series devices, the plastic feels more sturdy. The 200-series nuvi's are also slightly thinner than the 300-series nuvi's